White elephant, without a long argument mid-party

White elephant and Yankee swap work best when the group agrees on house rules before the first present is opened. These notes are a starting point you can read aloud, not an official rulebook. Agree on a spending cap, a steal limit, and whether a gift can be stolen back in the same turn.

Updated .

For a name draw instead of steals, use the Secret Santa tool. Gift-card terms are on the CFPB gift-card page. After the party, the bill-split tool can divide a check.

At a glance

Rule to agree on firstSuggested house rule
Spending cap and styleSet them before anyone shops
Steal limitFor example, two steals per gift
Immediate steal-backNot in the same turn under these rules
Final turnPlayer 1 may make one final steal

White elephant, Yankee swap, and similar gift steals work best when the group agrees on a few house rules before the first present is opened. The notes below are a simple starting point you can read aloud, not a trademarked official rulebook.

  1. Set a spending cap and a gift style (funny, useful, or either) before anyone shops.
  2. Wrap the gifts so they look the same enough that no one can steer toward a particular box.
  3. Put the gifts in a pile. Write numbers from 1 to the number of players and let each person draw a number.
  4. Player 1 unwraps a gift from the pile and shows it.
  5. Each later player may either unwrap a new gift from the pile or steal an already opened gift. If a gift is stolen, the person who lost it either unwraps a new gift or steals a different opened gift.
  6. Agree in advance on a steal limit, such as two steals per gift, so a popular item cannot bounce around forever. Once a gift has been stolen that many times, it stays with the last person who took it.
  7. A person who just had a gift stolen may not immediately steal it back in the same turn.
  8. After the last player has gone, player 1 may make one final steal. Then the exchange is over.

If you would rather skip the steal format entirely, use the Secret Santa draw instead.

Common questions

Is there one official white-elephant rulebook?

No. These are house rules you can read aloud, not a trademarked official rulebook.

How do you keep one gift from bouncing around forever?

Agree in advance on a steal limit, such as two steals per gift. Once a gift has been stolen that many times, it stays with the last person who took it.

Can someone steal a gift back immediately?

Under these house rules, a person who just had a gift stolen may not immediately steal it back in the same turn.

What if the group would rather assign names than steal gifts?

Use the Secret Santa draw instead.